For the past couple of months, I’ve been unhealthily into the ninth season of American Idol. I watch the show when it’s on and I pore through the blogs and news sites featuring anything about the show. The funny thing is, I’ve never really watched the show, but this time was different, because my niece’s friend, Katie Stevens, is in it. I’ve seen her perform a couple of times in some productions she’s been and often thought that she had such an incredible voice, which is why it didn’t come as a huge surprise when I heard she was trying out for American Idol.
Naturally, when the new season aired, I was glued to the TV and felt quite pleased when she made it in. I looked forward to hearing how she was doing every week and, also, to her first outing on the show, when she sang the Nina Simone original “Feelin’ Good.” I wasn’t crazy about the song, and it seemed like nobody was totally crazy about her performance as a whole. She was told to go younger and be 17, so she followed it up with Corinne Bailey Rae’s “Put Your Records On.” Still not young enough! Figure out who you are as an artist! she was told. She tried again with Kelly Clarkson’s “Breakaway,” about which none of the judges were happy.
One of my sisters and I took to dissecting every episode; call us crazed critic-wannabes. It seemed to me as though it’s the pressure to be young that was hounding her, and every week, she did her best to comply with the judges’ wishes, even though it’s evident that her voice and style weren’t young to begin with. They want to turn her into a pop princess when her voice is suited to something else. My sister theorized that because she looked like such a cute little doll, that counted against her, and so she was expected to come up with something sweet. One blog comment somewhere said, “If she went any younger, she’d be singing Barney songs.”
Everybody thought she was a goner when the top 12 was announced, which is why it was a complete shock when Lilly Scott was eliminated. And then the insane, bitter gripefest began, with many of the complaints being hurled against Katie as if it were her fault Lilly was eliminated. Initially, I was incensed in Katie’s behalf–you can tell I’m totally invested in this–and at the same time realized how brave she and all the other contestants were for putting themselves out there, in the glare of the world’s scrutiny. No wonder some celebrities say that they refuse to go online and look up any comments about themselves, because the criticism’s just terrible (which made me think that if I ever got around to writing my ode to Ben Barnes and posting it here to scream out how much I want to meet him and just frickin’ shake his hand, he would never get to read it anyway. Pfft.).
Then I noticed the tone that most people would take when they criticized, not just her, but another young’un like Aaron Kelly. Critics would bash them for appealing to the Hannah Montana generation, that they just got the votes of young people who knew how to text like crazy on their mobile phone compared to the older crowd, that they probably didn’t know any more music beyond Miley Cyrus and Taylor Swift, that there should be a higher age requirement to be able to join the competition, that they didn’t have enough life experiences to pour their hearts and souls into their performances. Frankly, I’m not really fond of young people, but even I have to say that those comments smack of discrimination, as if teenagers are stupid people who just get easily swayed by trends and know nothing about music, let alone life. Critics seem to have forgotten that when you’re young, you aren’t necessarily the idiot that adults think you are. I wonder if any of them recognize that they’ve become the kind of adult who puts down and talks down to kids and teenagers.
Last night’s Rolling Stones round had Katie singing “Wild Horses,” and for the first time, the judges were pleased with it. Personally, I was relieved that she finally got an opportunity to belt out a song; I’m not an expert on music, but she does have a big, deep, velvety voice that needs a lot of room to get out. I’m crossing my fingers for her, of course, although I have to say that I don’t think she’ll be the American Idol this year. Which isn’t necessarily a bad thing, since that would let her explore other options that would be more perfect for her.
My sister and I noted how vehement we get about criticisms against Katie, and are happy that our niece isn’t planning to join AI. If she did and people begin pelting her with insults, we will go to war.